There’s a lot of chatter among people who love meat about how to make that perfect steak crust. It’s likely if you ask, you’ll get many “tried and true” methods. I have an approach that works beautifully that I’d like to share with you. 

One thing. Look for a steak that’s about 1 ½ inches thick. Also, you want one with good marbling. The better quality steak you choose, the better the results.

Step One:

Dry the steak in your refrigerator for 1-3 days. Why? A dryer exterior makes for a better crisp. 

Step Two:

Bring the steak to room temperature. Using a Chef’s Knife, lightly score the steak.

Step Three

1 hour before cooking, sprinkle some sea salt on the steak evenly. You can also look at other spice options like Cuso’s Gravel Seasoning. The great thing about Gravel is that it adds to the crust you’re developing.

Step Four

Ah, the pan. I prefer cast iron, but you can use carbon steel or stainless as alternatives. Heat up the pan over high heat. 

Step Five

Once the pan is heated, press the steak onto the surface (for an even crust). Do not move the steak. Leave it for about 1-3 minutes. You can use tongues to peek and see if it needs more time.

Step Six

Once the first side has developed crust, flip the steak over and sear the second side. Again, push the steak down so it lies flat. 

Step Seven

Baste both sides of the steak with a generous amount of butter. 

Step Eight

Move the steak into the oven under the broiler (350F). Watch the internal temperature. You’re looking for 125F for medium rare (it will come up 5 degrees while resting). For a thick steak, you will probably need another 2 minutes on each side. 

PitMaster’s Memo

So, what’s the big deal about steak crust? There are four things you can depend on when you crust a steak properly.

1. The meat won’t get soggy
2. The texture has a great mouth feel
3. You can’t beat the flavor
4. Makes for an impressive presentation

Sides

Eggplant with Tzatziki sauce

Garlic sauteed mushrooms

Salmon wrapped shrimp

Sauteed green beans with pine nuts

Stuffed tomatoes

Dessert

Apple-pear pie

Chocolate mousse

Coconut chiffon cake

Creme Brulee

Rhubarb custard

From the Bar

Dry martini

Light lager 

Rye

Sweet mint tea

Zinfandel