Grilled Pinecone Hot Dogs

Introduction

In the United States, people collectively eat 20 billion (with a B) hot dogs annually, typically topped with mustard and ketchup. In part, the low cost proves attractive, especially when feeding a lot of people. But then, there’s the flavor, the versatility, and the ease in making this classic food.

Sure, you could just toss a few wieners on the grill and call it a day. Or you can make these playful pinecone hot dogs, braised in a buttery hot sauce to caramelize. These are a whole different kind of taste-and-texture experience. Pinecone hot dogs satisfy those who crave sultry heat thanks to Cuso’s Lava Barbecue Sauce. Chicken is not the only thing hot off the grill that’s “finger lickin’ good.”

A little scoring, and your grill works a little fiery magic. Hot dogs bloom, edges crisp, and every bit of flavor stays in the little pockets. They’re irresistible! Truthfully, pinecone hot dogs make an ordinary weiner look rather lamentable.

Hankering for Hot Dogs

People love pine cone hot dogs for many reasons:

Easy finger food
Kid-friendly (including adult “kids”)
Price point (they don’t burn a hole in your wallet)
Satisfying crisp. Smoky with a juicy center
Tasty: holds sauces, glazes, and rubs

What’s With the Name?

One look at this dish and you’ll quickly see why they’re called pinecone hot dogs. Deep cross-hatching (or spiral cut) makes the hot dog flare out when heated (typically barbecued), opening like pinecone scales. It quickly became a favorite technique for backyard grilling and social media vids. Cooks appreciate the interesting visual and the fact that all those nooks and crannies hold a heap of flavor and smoky nuances. You bite into crispy, caramelized ridges with sauce and spices trapped inside, and a soft interior.

The Best Hot Dogs for Pinecone Hot Dogs

Not all hot dogs are created equal for making pinecone hot dogs. You need a sturdy dog for this method to work. Jumbo styles make scoring easier. All-beef hot dogs char beautifully and have firmness.

Natural casing franks are snappy. Brats can work, too. The thicker the hot dog, the bigger the pinecone-like scales.

Just avoid skinny, cheap franks. You won’t be happy with the outcome.

What are the Benefits of Cross-Hatching Hot Dogs?

Cross-hatching is your proverbial secret spice in this recipe. It maximizes crispiness by creating edges, which act as flavor pockets. The hot dogs cook evenly, and cross-hatching creates the visual appeal.

The approach is simple. Use a good Chef’s Knife. Cut diagonal lines in the hot dog, taking care not to slice through. Now turn the hot dog around and repeat so you see Xs. Try to keep your cuts spaced out evenly.

Grilled Pinecone Hot Dogs

Watch people’s faces light up when you serve this fantastic twist on classic hot dogs. Before you grill, the hot dogs are scored with a cross-hatch pattern, creating a pinecone-like appearance. The edges get crispy, while the little pockets hold tight to the flavor of any sauce or seasoning you use. Add a dipping bowl of dressing or glaze, and the results are tantalizing and visually stunning.

Comment Pin

Prep Time

10 minutes

Cook Time

1 hour 30 minutes

Total Time

1 hour 40 minutes

Ingredients for Savory Pinecone Hot Dogs

6 hot dogs
1 cup Cuso’s low-calorie Lava Barbecue Sauce
½ cup Cuso’s Spicy Garlic Buffalo Seasoning
1 stick of butter
1 tbsp minced garlic
Remaining bottle of Lava Barbecue Sauce
Green onion (garnish)
Blue cheese (dip)
Toothpicks

Instructions for Grilling Smoky Pine Cone Hot Dogs

Pat the hot dogs dry

Cross-hatch the hot dogs

Roll them in Cuso’s Lava sauce (this acts as a binder)

Sprinkle the franks with Cuso’s Spicy Garlic Buffalo Seasoning

Grill them at 300°F for 30 minutes

In the meantime, make the sauce

Melt the butter with the garlic

Add the Lava Sauce

Remove the hot dogs from the grill

Quarter each of them

Put the pieces in the sauce, and back to the grill at 200°F for 1 hour

Garnish with green onion

Blue Cheese dip on the side

How to Make Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing

Ingredients

1 cup mayonnaise
1/2 cup sour cream
¼ cup crumbled blue cheese
¼ cup crumbled gorgonzola
1–2 tbsp milk (for thinning, if desired)
1 tsp white wine
Salt & pepper to taste

Instructions:

Mix everything together before you start cooking. Let it sit in the refrigerator for at least 1 hour, or overnight for full flavor.

Flavor Variations for Pine Cone Style Cooking

There are a few tricks you can use to switch up the flavor profile of your pinecone hot dogs

Binders:

These hold seasonings in place and offer moisture. Options include mustard (tanginess), olive oil (very light), mayo (rich), garlic aioli (spicy hint), and honey (a little sweet).

Rubs:

Cuso’s Tequila Lime Habanero (bold), Cuso’s Roasted Garlic and Onion (aromatic and savory), Cuso’s Chipotle Razz (fruity heat), Cuso’s Jala Pickle Ranch (skip the dill on the side), or Cuso’s Gravel Seasoning(for extra texture).

Sauce:

Sweet Thai chili, brown sugar hot sauce, Teriyaki, Hot-honey-miso, maple-mustard, bourbon glaze, caramelized onion, balsamic glaze. Chef’s Tip: Wait until the last few minutes of grilling to apply the sauce in order to avoid burning.

Toppings

If you are planning on rolls and toppings, keep the hot dog whole. Add bacon bits, freshly chopped onion, sautéed mushrooms, pulled pork, chili, coleslaw, kimchi, pickled radish, arugula, fig jam, grilled pineapple, or pickles.

Common Mistakes when Making Smoky Pinecone Hot Dogs

Cutting too deep or shallow. When too deep, the hot dog falls apart. When too shallow, the frank doesn’t bloom.
Using a pan that's too small for braising the hot dog bites in the sauce. Don’t overcrowd.
Skipping the binder. The herbs won’t stick.
Cooking at too high a heat. This burns the exterior rather than crisping it.

Tips for Success with Grilled Pinecone Hot Dogs

Be careful with your knife cuts
Pat the hot dogs dry before applying the binder and seasoning
Let the grill preheat completely
Keep the temperature at a medium heat
Turn the hot dogs regularly so they cook and open evenly
If using buns, toast them first

Storage & Reheating Instructions: Pinecone Hot Dogs

Storage

The hot are good for 3-4 days in the refrigerator

Reheating

Grilling will bring back the hot dogs’ crispness

Air flying works effectively

Oven warm them at 350°F for 8–10 minutes

Some of Jack’s Other Great Hot Dog Recipes

Seattle-Style Hot Dogs: Charred hot dogs with cheddar and cream cheese, topped with crispy onions and jalapeño slices.

Hot Dog Burnt Ends: Warning. These are addictive. Charred mini-wieners braised in butter and mango-habanero sauce.

Loaded Cheese Dogs: Bacon-wrapped beef dogs topped with jalapeno-bourbon baked beans and loads of cheese.

FAQs

Do I need special tools to cut pinecone hot dogs?

Nothing fancy. Just a kitchen knife.

Can I make them in an air fryer?

Absolutely. Frying at 375°F for about 4 minutes per side yields nicely crisp results

Oven cooking? What about making pinecone hot dogs on the stove top?

If you’re using the oven, set the temperature to 400°F and cook for about 12 minutes. On the stovetop, turn the heat to medium. Use an iron skillet if possible. Rotate regularly so the dog opens evenly on all sides.

Are they spicy?

A little. You can tone them down by using regular barbecue sauce and rub.

Can I use plant-based hot dogs?

Yes, but you have to be careful. Plant-based hot dogs are typically softer so be gentle with your score marks.

Can I smoke pinecone hot dogs?

This is my happy place. Smoking hot dogs over the grill adds another layer of flavor to this meal. Lean into hickory, cherry, or apple smoking wood. Start on low so the smoke saturates, then turn up the grill toward the end to crisp the hot dogs perfectly.

What kind of buns are best?

This recipe doesn’t require buns, but there’s no saying you can stuff 3-4 pieces into a great brioche bun. Pretzel buns, potato rolls, Hawaiian sweet rolls, and Kaiser rolls also work well.

My hot dog didn’t open like a pinecone. Why?

You most likely didn’t cut the hot dog deeply enough. Alternatively, the hot dogs were too thin to show a real difference.

Can I prep pinecone hot dogs ahead of time?

Yes. Go ahead and score them. Then cover and refrigerate until you are ready to cook. If you wish, you can also make the sauce ahead of time, too. Just heat it up before adding the smoked franks.

Are there other foods that benefit from hatch cutting before grilling?

Several, actually. Potatoes, pineapple, carrots, stone fruit, parsnip, sausage, kielbasa, eggplant, sweet potato, and zucchini are all examples.

Suggestions about side dishes, desserts, and beverages that pair with pinecone hot dogs?

Sides:

Classic side dishes for pinecone hot dogs work just fine. Macaroni salad, apple slaw, scalloped potato, shoe peg corn, tomato and cucumber salad, fried pickles, sweet chipotle chips, or chili fries.

Dessert:

S’mores. Grilled plums with honey, banana pudding, mini fruit pies, cinnamon apples, caramel cake

Beverages:

Mint lemonade, peach bourbon iced tea, light lagers, birch beer

Final Thoughts

You can pull out grilled pinecone hot dogs as a barbecue surprise. No one has to know your secret until you serve! It’s fun to have a little theatre and mystery. And on hot days, you can’t beat cooking outside.

Those of you who have tuned into my Instagram vids (@CusoCuts) know that grilling is a passion, as is creating fresh food ideas. Keep watching! You never know what recipe will appear next.

Sign up for our newsletter. Here you’ll get the insider information on what’s happening with our all-natural, non-GMO seasoning line, low-calorie sauces, and even pure Wagyu beef tallow. We tell you about sales events, too.

Time to get grilling!